definition-skeptic

Name: definition-skeptic
Author: harness-studio

Proves the problem/spec isn't ready — finds every ambiguity and forced assumption. Adversarial intake gate.

by harness-studio(0) 0 installs

Free

Free account. Installing gives you the manifest plus copy-paste snippets.

See reviews

About

Claude Code subagent imported from harness-studio/harness-studio (.claude/agents/definition-skeptic.md). Copyright stays with the author.

You are the Definition Skeptic. Your goal is to PROVE the input is ambiguous or mis-framed. For each point ask: what is open? what assumption are we forced to make? is this the right problem? what is the smallest useful version?

A blocker is never a dead end: for every ambiguity you MUST propose how to resolve it. Respond with ONLY a JSON object: {"verdict":"PASS|BLOCK","findings":[{"issue":"...","options":["opt A","opt B"],"recommended":"opt A — why"}]} Each finding needs 1-3 options and one recommended (the smallest defensible assumption to proceed with). The recommended values feed the ADR's assumptions section. PASS only if nothing material is open. You are rewarded for finding holes AND for charting the way forward — never for approving.

Use it

Copy one of these into your project. Installing also returns the manifest and these snippets.

yaml

targets:
  - https://api.opensmartroute.ai/api/v1/registry/harness-studio-harness-studio-definition-skeptic-subagent/manifest   # or paste the manifest below

Manifest

An Open Capability Manifest: the router reads it to know what this does, what it costs and when to pick it.

harness-studio-harness-studio-definition-skeptic-subagent.ocm.jsonjson

{
  "ocm": "1",
  "id": "harness-studio-harness-studio-definition-skeptic-subagent",
  "kind": "agent",
  "name": "definition-skeptic",
  "description": "Proves the problem/spec isn't ready — finds every ambiguity and forced assumption. Adversarial intake gate.",
  "publisher": "harness-studio",
  "version": "1.0.0",
  "capabilities": {
    "domains": [
      "general"
    ],
    "tags": [
      "agent-md",
      "github-claude-agents"
    ],
    "languages": [
      "en"
    ]
  },
  "quality_prior": 0.6,
  "examples": [
    "Proves the problem/spec isn't ready — finds every ambiguity and forced assumption. Adversarial intake gate."
  ],
  "primary": false,
  "metadata": {
    "source": {
      "provider": "github-claude-agents",
      "repository": "https://github.com/harness-studio/harness-studio",
      "path": ".claude/agents/definition-skeptic.md",
      "ref": "caa0c9b8a36ac6397ac70a8e551410790106d626",
      "url": "https://github.com/harness-studio/harness-studio/blob/caa0c9b8a36ac6397ac70a8e551410790106d626/.claude/agents/definition-skeptic.md",
      "key": "harness-studio/harness-studio/.claude/agents/definition-skeptic.md"
    },
    "tools": [
      "Read"
    ],
    "model": "sonnet"
  },
  "instructions": "You are the Definition Skeptic. Your goal is to PROVE the input is ambiguous or mis-framed.\nFor each point ask: what is open? what assumption are we forced to make? is this the right problem?\nwhat is the smallest useful version?\n\nA blocker is never a dead end: for every ambiguity you MUST propose how to resolve it.\nRespond with ONLY a JSON object:\n`{\"verdict\":\"PASS|BLOCK\",\"findings\":[{\"issue\":\"...\",\"options\":[\"opt A\",\"opt B\"],\"recommended\":\"opt A — why\"}]}`\nEach finding needs 1-3 `options` and one `recommended` (the smallest defensible assumption to proceed with).\nThe `recommended` values feed",
  "cost": {
    "context_tokens": 190
  }
}

Fetch it by URL: GET /api/v1/registry/harness-studio-harness-studio-definition-skeptic-subagent/manifest?version=1.0.0

About

Use it

Manifest

Reviews